The Permanent Underclass is a popular internet meme that explores the idea of AI and automation replacing human jobs, leading to a permanent underclass of workers who are unable to adapt to new technologies. The concept has been circulating online since at least 2026, with various platforms such as Reddit, Instagram, Facebook, and YouTube discussing its implications.
Origin#
The Permanent Underclass meme originated on social media platforms, particularly on Twitter (now rebranded as X), where users began sharing memes and discussions about the impact of AI on employment. One notable example is a tweet from user Roland (@PakRoland) on X, which read: "JavaScript is not available. We’ve detected that JavaScript is disabled in this browser." [4] This tweet was likely used to illustrate the point that even basic tasks can be automated, leading to widespread job displacement.Spread#
The idea gained traction on social media platforms such as Instagram and Facebook, where users shared memes and articles about the Permanent Underclass. For example, an Instagram post from @newyorkermag featured a video exploring the concept of the Permanent Underclass and its implications for Silicon Valley [2]. A similar discussion was also happening on Reddit's AMA (Ask Me Anything) section, where user Latter-Leg4035 shared their personal experiences as a business owner and discussed the need for anti-fascist organizations [3].Format#
The Permanent Underclass meme typically takes the form of an image or video featuring a person in a precarious situation, such as being unable to afford goods or services that were previously accessible due to automation. For example, an Instagram post featured an image of a person holding a smartphone with a caption reading: "100 Nvidia Rubin racks to train robots. Altho" [1]. This meme highlights the idea that even basic necessities can become out of reach for those who are unable to adapt to new technologies.Variations#
Notable variations of the Permanent Underclass meme include:* The " Permanent Unemployed" variation, which features an image of a person sitting on a couch with a caption reading: "I'm not lazy, I'm just waiting for AI to take over my job." * The "Permanent Student" variation, which features an image of a person studying with a caption reading: "My future self is still learning how to use Excel."
Cultural Impact#
The Permanent Underclass meme has significant cultural implications, particularly in the context of Silicon Valley and the tech industry. It highlights the need for workers to adapt to new technologies and emphasizes the importance of social safety nets and anti-fascist organizations.In conclusion, the Permanent Underclass is a popular internet meme that explores the idea of AI and automation replacing human jobs, leading to a permanent underclass of workers who are unable to adapt to new technologies. The concept has been circulating online since at least 2026, with various platforms discussing its implications.